At three, Goethe screamed that an “ugly” child must be taken away. Years later, when his brother died, he answered his mother’s question about love not with tears, but with a bundle of papers he had written for him. Margaret Fuller opens this collection of reviews, narratives, essays, and poems by asking how we can judge a genius who seems to resist every measure. In her review of Menzel’s view of Goethe, she argues that the critic sees the poet from outside, while Goethe’s works keep leading readers “on and on,” into a deeper understanding of their maker. The debate reaches beyond one writer: what does it mean to measure a life by an ideal, or by what that person was given to become? Can any judgment of Goethe hold its ground as we grow? With centuries of literature, it's inevitable that some will fall through the cracks. We hunt down public domain works and restore them so they're not lost to the world. Who are we? We're Cairn Press. Our background is in design, publishing, typography, and technology. These skills fuel our mission to create the highest quality Public Domain eBooks available online, at an affordable price. We give them the treatment they deserve; our proprietary process restores books for a better overall user experience in design, readability, and e-reader compatibility.