A sea king’s children climb from the waves to call their mother from church; she sees them through the window, but keeps her eyes on the holy book. What makes this haunting poem, by a young writer signing himself “A.,” poetry—and what makes it fail? In this essay, James Anthony Froude takes up Matthew Arnold’s early poems and the chilly reception that greeted them. He admires the spell of “The Forsaken Merman” and the moonlit splendor of “Mycerinus,” yet refuses to let beauty alone settle the question. Arnold’s uneven work leads Froude into a sharper argument about verse, prose, artistic discipline, and the public’s right to judge. His verdict is no easy compliment: genuine originality, he suggests, must answer to forms tested by experience. Can a poet break those old rules and still make them sing? With centuries of literature, it's inevitable that some will fall through the cracks. We hunt down public domain works and restore them so they're not lost to the world. Who are we? We're Cairn Press. Our background is in design, publishing, typography, and technology. These skills fuel our mission to create the highest quality Public Domain eBooks available online, at an affordable price. We give them the treatment they deserve; our proprietary process restores books for a better overall user experience in design, readability, and e-reader compatibility.